Sunday, July 23, 2017

RSS intends to Kill Rabindranath,the dead poet walking live after Gandhi! RSS is greater threat than any foreign invasion because it is killing Indian civilization and the history of India and not to mention the traditional Hindu religion so democrat and tolerant! Hindutva brigaed seems to be admant to wipe out Bengali nationalism,Bengali identity and Bengali connectivity with the universe and civilization.Without Rabindranath neither Bengal nor Bangaldesh may have any identity whatsoever. May we imagine Hindi without Urdu words?If Hindi is to be yet another gomata,the sacred cow,how it would include the non Hindi non Hindu demography to become national or global language, Batra may not be expected to have the vision. Palash Biswas


RSS intends to Kill Rabindranath,the dead poet walking live after Gandhi!


RSS is greater threat than any foreign invasion because it is killing Indian civilization and the history of India and not to mention the traditional Hindu religion so democrat and tolerant!


Hindutva brigade seems to be adamant to wipe out Bengali nationalism,Bengali identity and Bengali connectivity with the universe and civilization.Without Rabindranath neither Bengal nor Bangaldesh may have any identity whatsoever.


May we imagine Hindi without Urdu words?If Hindi is to be yet another gomata,the sacred cow,how it would include the non Hindi non Hindu demography to become national or global language, Batra may not be expected to have the vision.


Palash Biswas


Dina Nath Batra again: He wants Tagore, Urdu words off school texts.Mind you,Dinanath Batra is a retired school teacher and the founder of educational activist organisations Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti and Shiksha Sanskriti Utthan.


Bengal is flodded. It is raining heavily for three days and It would be raining heavily for next 48 hours.Kolakata and Howrah waterlogged. Rest of Bengal is also waterlogged.


But Hindutva brigade seems to be adamant to wipe out Bengali nationalism,Bengali identity and Bengali connectivity with the universe and civilization.


Without Rabindranath neither Bengal nor Bangaldesh may have any identity whatsoever.


Not only Bengalies worldwide,the citizens of Indian civilization owe much to Rabindranath for his idea of India which is all about unity in diversity and humanity ultimate.


It is perhaps the greatest attack on Indian civilization after the demise of Mohanjodaro and Harrapaa.Greater than the foreign attack against the integrity and unity of Indian humanity because it is going to disintegrate the social fabrics to make in digital Hindu Nation.It would kill Indian Nation, its constitution and Secular democracy,Unity in diversity.It is the agenda of racist ethnic cleansing in digital corporate Hindu Nation as majority people are subjected to monopolistic Racist Genocide.


It is borgi attack all round yet again as Along with five pages of recommendations, the Nyas, headed by Dina Nath Batra, a former head of Vidya Bharati, the education wing of the RSS, has attached pages from several NCERT textbooks, with the portions that it wants removed marked and underlined.


We may hate English just because the history of British Imperialist Raj in India.But the fact remains that English remains most inclusive.Even now,in free India,we have to interact in English to touch every corner of India.


We may not interact with rest of humanity without English.English diction has included every foreign sound meaning something different and we have words from south Asia abundant in English.It also included French, Roman, Latin, German  with other European languages as well as African and Latin American dialects.


English is enhanced by a number of Indian writers.While English writers contribute English from every part of India.


How many Non Hindi language Indian writers and poets have been included in Hindi literature?


We talk so mush so for making Hindi National language.The slogan for Hindu nation is Hindu,Hindi and Hindustan.We want to compete with English making Hindi a global language.


May we imagine Hindi without Urdu words?


If Hindi is to be yet another gomata, the sacred cow,how it would include the non Hindi non Hindu demography to become national or global language, Batra mayenot be expected to have the vision.

Have we?


Rabindra Nath compoesed Natinal anthem of India and Bangaldesh freedom struggle inspired by his poem Amaar Sonar Bangla aami tomay Bhalobasi,which is finally the national anthem of Bangladesh.Indian traditional philosophy,its culture,folk and spritualism have been the theme of Rabindra works more tahn any one else.


Geetanjali is all about India,Indian philosophy of life and Indian nationalism which consists of diverse streams of humanities merged on the soil of Bharat Teerth.


Now,the worshippers of Godse, Golvalkar, Savarkar and Hitler intend to Kill Rabindranath,the dead poet walking live in every sphere of India civilization after they killed someone like Gandhi who united Indian people in freedom struggle against British rule.


RSS is greater threat than any foreign invasion because it is killing Indian civilization and the history of India and not to mention the traditional Hindu religion so democrat and tolerant!


An education body affiliated to ruling BJP's ideological parent RSS wants to "sanitise" NCERT's Class 1-12 Hindi textbooks by removing Urdu and Persian words.


The Shiksha Sanskriti Utthan Nyas, under RSS ideologue Dinanath Batra, also wants to remove verses of Mirza Ghalib and other Urdu poets from the books.


RSS activist Dinanath Batra, who heads the Shiksha Sanskriti Utthan Nyas, has sent recommendations to the NCERT to remove some portions of school textbooks.

These recommendations include removal of English, Urdu and Arabic words, references to Mughal emperors as generous, former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's apology over the 1984 riots, and the sentence that around 2000 Muslims were allegedly killed in the Gujarat riots, according to the Indian Express.

The Nyas has sent about five pages of such recommendations along with pages from the NCERT books with highlighted portions of what to remove, the report says. Atul Kothari, Nyas's secretary and former RSS missionary told IE that this kind of content in textbooks was a sort of appeasement and it was uninspiring to teach children about riots. He said that histories of Indian kings like Shivaji and Maharana Pratap, Hindu monk Vivekananda and Indian nationalist Subhas Chandra Bose do not find such a place in the textbooks.

Earlier, Nyas had campaigned for the removal of A K Ramanujan's essay Three Hundred Ramayanas: Five Examples and Three Thoughts on Translation from the University of Delhi's syllabus. It had also moved court to demand removal of The Hindus by Wendy Doniger.

Nyas has marked portions from textbooks for their removal. For instance, from Class XII Political Science book, Nyas wants the mention of National Conference of J&K as a secular organisation removed.


With the NCERT revising its textbooks, the Nyas has written to the government to "clean" Hindi books of words such as Eeman, Rujhan, Shiddat and Taaqat.


The organisation has come up with a booklet, a copy of which is with DNA, in which it has mentioned various examples from the books. One of the examples is a verse of Ghalib, which is taught to students in one of the Hindi chapters. 


The verse, from Jamun Ka Ped, reads: "Hum ne mana ki tagaful na karoge lekin khak ho jayenge ham tum ko khabar hone taq." 


Dinanath Batra, who is often criticised for "saffronising" education, has in the past also written to the government to change content in texts, specially History ones.


He has been advocating that the use of foreign languages in schools should be banned. In his suggestions to the government on the New Education Policy, he had written that Hindi should be made the medium of instruction, instead of English.


"I have read all Hindi textbooks from Class 1 to 12 and found a number of errors. The usage of Urdu, Persian and even English words in Hindi books has made the language very heavy and created a challenge for students. Instead of being a source of entertainment and learning, Hindi chapters have become uninteresting for students," Batra told DNA.


"We have approached the HRD Ministry and have also been taking up this issue with NCERT that they should remove all non-Hindi words from their Hindi textbooks. Now that they are revising their textbooks, we have demanded that these changes should be made," he added.


He said that his earlier suggestions of changes in History textbooks were considered but it's the changes in Hindi that the council is not ready to change.


NCERT officials refused to comment on the issue.

Indian Express reports this morning:Remove English, Urdu and Arabic words, a poem by the revolutionary poet Pash and a couplet by Mirza Ghalib; the thoughts of Rabindranath Tagore; extracts from painter M F Husain's autobiography; references to the Mughal emperors as benevolent, to the BJP as a "Hindu" party, and to the National Conference as "secular"; an apology tendered by former prime minister Manmohan Singh over the 1984 riots; and a sentence that "nearly 2,000 Muslims were killed in Gujarat in 2002". These are some of the many recommendations the RSS-affiliated Shiksha Sanskriti Utthan Nyas has sent to the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), which recently sought suggestions from the public on reviewing school textbooks of all classes.

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/dina-nath-batra-again-he-wants-tagore-urdu-words-off-school-texts-4764094/